The Three Musketeers (1948) Reviewed

The Three Musketeers from 1948 is neither the best nor the worst of all the film adaptations of Alexandre Dumas' classic swashbuckling epic. As an adaptation of the novel itself, it is colorful, lively, and ambitious, but it is also a clumsy adaptation in the standard Hollywood tradition. Moments that are meant to loom large both in plot and dramatic impact are instead rushed and reduced. The moments where it lingers longest are overwrought and paradoxically (though unintentionally) invite detachment rather than empathy. The casting choices promise more than they deliver. Vincent Price would seem to be made for the role of Cardinal Richelieu, but his portrayal seems as flat as the script. Frank Morgan as Louis XIII carries himself more like a befuddled shopkeeper than a king, Angela Lansbury as Queen Anne could be any unhappy housewife, and the titular trio could be any group of boisterous, well-intentioned fops despite the moderately tortured posturings of Van Heflin's Athos. Lana Turner falls short of embodying the evil for which Lady de Winter is infamous, which is a serious shortcoming for so important an antagonist. The film's greatest asset is Gene Kelly as D'Artagnan in what must have been a conscious attempt to mimic Douglas Fairbanks in the same role in 1921. In fact, the film succeeds most where it attempts to adapt its 1921 predecessor rather than the novel. Kelly's D'Artagnan is essentially Fairbanks' D'Artagnan with sound and color, just as dynamic physically and comically, and just as prone to melodramatic telegraphy. With a better screenplay, this 1948 version of The Three Musketeers could have been — and ought to have been — much more than a one-man show.

Writing: Mediocre
Directing: Fair
Acting: Fair
Cinematography: Good
Stunts: Great
Swordplay: Good
Panache: Good

Overall Rating: Fair
Swashbuckling Rank: Good


[Originally posted in Cuparius.com on 20 May 2011.]


Addendum

Written by: Robert Ardry
Based on: The Three Musketeers by Alexandre Dumas
Directed by: George Sidney
Performed by: Lana Turner, Gene Kelly, June Allyson, Van Heflin, Angela Lansbury, et al.